During E3, Tim Shafter of Double Fine Productions has said that Brutal Legend 2 will eventually happen.
During an informal Q&A discussion hosted by Jack Black at the E3 Coliseum, Schafer made some statements about a second Brutal Legend game. The original title was well received by fans and the sequel is something that has been after for some time.
When an audience member asked about Brutal Legend 2 during the Q&A session Schafer stated with some confidence that “someday we’ll make that game”. (Via Gamespot).
Brutal Legend 2 was in the planning stages a few years ago until publisher EA cancelled the project.